The Good

• Superior Absorbency and Leak Protection: “Unfortunately I do actually like them better than any other ones and I’m super mad about it. They really helped our little guy not leak.” (56 upvotes) Many parents praised Coterie for its strong performance, especially for babies who frequently leak through other diapers.
• Overnight Reliability: “We use Millie Moons mostly and Coterie for overnight because I am not the monopoly man.” (56 upvotes) Even cost-conscious parents admitted Coterie shines at night, keeping babies dry through long stretches.
• No Diaper Rash or Irritation: “0 diaper rashes, 0 leakage issues overnight (7pm–7am).” (32 upvotes) Multiple users reported that their babies’ skin stayed healthier with Coterie compared to mainstream brands.
• Softness and Premium Feel: “We have found them to be a little more absorbent and it works well for us.” (59 upvotes) Parents frequently described the material as “buttery soft” and gentle on sensitive skin.
• Specialized Use Case: “Coterie diapers are great. We use Costco Huggies for our daily driver, but we also usually have a pack of Coteries for longer stretches like overnights.” (59 upvotes) Many families reserve Coterie for night use, travel, or long outings when performance matters most.

The Not So Good

• Sizing Runs Small: “Coterie has smaller weight parameters and definitely run smaller than other brands we’ve tried.” (31 upvotes) Several parents found themselves needing to size up sooner than expected, which added to the overall cost.
• Occasional Blowouts: “I bet you have a size issue more than anything.” (23 upvotes) When leaks did occur, users attributed them mostly to Coterie’s narrow fit rather than absorbency problems.
• PFAS and “Clean” Marketing Debates: “Just wanted to add that there hasn’t been any published proof that Coterie diapers contain PFAS as far as I know. Someone filed a lawsuit which Coterie claims will get tossed.” (19 upvotes) While no evidence confirms PFAS content, the lawsuit raised ongoing skepticism among eco-conscious parents.

Comparison to Alternatives

• Mainstream Brands:
  • Huggies / Pampers: “The only thing making me feel good about Parents’ Choice diapers is that they work lol. Trust me I’d love to be buying cuter ones but this is where we are.” (28 upvotes)
  • Kirkland (Costco): “Kirkland diapers—the Costco brand—have worked great for our second! We used Pampers for our first and they’re great too, but more expensive.” (30 upvotes)
• Premium Alternatives:
  • Millie Moon: “Millie Moon at Target for that price is so wonderful. They are excellent diapers.” (41 upvotes)
  • Honest: “Honest worked fine in the lil baby stage but I’ve found they don’t hold up well to cruising and walking.” (24 upvotes)

Overall, Reddit parents often found Millie Moon to perform nearly as well as Coterie at a lower price point, while Huggies and Kirkland were praised for their value and reliability.

Tips from Reddit Parents

1. Nail the Fit: “I’d 100% try to size up. Blowouts are a sign of the wrong size.” (81 upvotes)
2. Expect Trial and Error: “Babies are all shaped differently and it takes some trial and error — I think we tried 5 or 6 brands before we found one that my son doesn’t leak in.” (100 upvotes)
3. Save the Fancy Ones for Overnight: “We use Costco Huggies for our daily driver, but also usually have a pack of Coteries for longer stretches like overnights.” (59 upvotes)

The Verdict

Coterie diapers earns high marks from Reddit parents for leak protection, overnight reliability, and baby comfort, but divides opinion on whether it’s worth the price.

Those who love it say it’s “life-changing” for dry nights and sensitive skin. Those who don’t see it as a “luxury tax” on a product category where mainstream brands already perform well.

• Best for: parents willing to splurge for premium comfort or use it selectively for nighttime.
• Skip if: you prioritize cost-effectiveness , brands like Millie Moon, Huggies, or Kirkland deliver solid results at a fraction of the price.

---