The Good

• Quality and Design: “Great T-shirts and chore coats. They source high quality fabrics. Particularly their madras.” (55 upvotes)
• Brand Growth: “Used to live around SoHo and always pop into Alex Mill‘s original little store… Been fun to see them grow up.” (55 upvotes)
• Natural Fabrics: “A lot of 100% cotton instead of acrylic blends and that sort.” (39 upvotes)
• Overall Impression: “Alex Mill is solid. A step above J Crew.” (34 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Lack of Transparency: “They’re not at all transparent about where their clothes are manufactured, the process by which they do so, etc.” (41 upvotes)
• Inconsistent Sizing: “Sizing is a bit all over the place so careful on Final Sale.” (55 upvotes)
• Fabric Issues: “Some of their stuff has garbage quality fabric as well so make sure to check.” (39 upvotes)

Comparison to Alternatives

• “One step above J Crew“ (41 upvotes)
• “I’d put Alex Mill somewhere above J Crew and below Billy Reid.” (55 upvotes)
• “Just better than J Crew at four times the price? Lol.” (28 upvotes)
• “It looks like the same basic stuff Madewell and J.Crew already sell, but a slight bit more minimalistic. Reminds me a bit of Uniqlo.” (39 upvotes)

Tips & Tricks

• Check Fabric Content: “Make sure to check” before buying (39 upvotes).
• Go for Natural Fibers: 100% cotton items earn more praise than blends.
• Sizing Tools: “Stuff looks good but final sale and no size chart makes me hesitant.” (32 upvotes)

The Verdict

Reddit’s take on Alex Mill is mixed. Fans highlight the quality and design of its T-shirts, chore coats, and madras fabrics, positioning the brand above J.Crew for design and quality/

But inconsistent sizing, questionable transparency, and uneven fabric quality raise red flags. Most users advise checking fiber content carefully, avoiding final sale items, and deciding whether the brand’s higher price tag aligns with your style priorities.

---