Henry Rose Reddit Community Reviews

If you’ve seen Henry Rose pop up in your feed or at Sephora and wondered whether the hype is real, hope these reviews will help you.

The brand, co-founded by Michelle Pfeiffer and known for its clean formulations, has stirred up plenty of opinions from curious fragrance fans and those who are ingredient cautious.

The Good

A favorite for skin scent lovers: “Sheep’s Clothing by Henry Rose (similar to Glossier You)” (10 upvotes)
Flora Carnivora has a cult following: “I’m obsessed with Flora Carnivora! Planning on ordering a bottle” (11 upvotes)
Queens & Monsters and Fog stand out: “I like the house overall; my favorites are Queens & Monsters and Fog, and I also like Jake’s House” (8 upvotes)
Jake’s House is a solid everyday scent: Frequently mentioned as approachable and versatile
Enjoyable and wearable: “It’s super fresh and a happy scent. I feel like it lingers some on clothes and bedding” (11 upvotes)
Celebrity branding appeal: “I like pretending like I smell like Michelle Pfeiffer tbh.” (11 upvotes)

The Not So Good

Longevity is a recurring complaint: “I really do wish it lasted a little longer, as this stuff disappears within an hour for me” (10 upvotes); “Longevity is despicable for all of them.” (15 upvotes)
Too safe or forgettable for some: “While all of them could be described as ‘nice’, they are, frankly, all forgettable. They all share very similar DNA.” (15 upvotes)
Overpriced for what you get: “Anyways they’re all overpriced. Especially considering how meh they are.” (88 upvotes)
Names can feel misleading: “The names make me giggle because they’re so not fitting, ‘Menace’ sounds like it’d be a dark, unusual scent and it’s just aquatic musk.” (46 upvotes)
Some scents skew too youthful or powdery: “It’s so feminine (floral & powdery)… I wonder if it’s really for a young girl” (11 upvotes)
Dave’s scent profile is divisive: “Indolic scents… in Dave by Henry Rose. In low doses they typically smell like flowers, but high doses or particularly sensitive noses lead to a fecal odor” (11 upvotes)
Packaging doesn’t feel premium: “The packaging is definitely lacking and is why I held off buying it as long as I did. It looks like a dollar store perfume” (15 upvotes)

Compared to others

Often compared to Glossier You: Especially for Sheep’s Clothing (10 upvotes)
Talked about alongside niche but accessible brands: Nest, Commodity, Kayali
Part of the clean beauty conversation: Shows up in discussions with brands like Dedcool for sensitive skin and migraine-safe formulations
Allergy-friendly for some: “I guess it’s ideal for people with allergies.” (12 upvotes)
Alternative options suggested: “Eden Perfumes, they have all vegan/cruelty free dupes of designer perfumes which are very accurate! They allow you to refill the glass bottles (even via post) and as far as I know they’re pretty sustainable and nontoxic.” (14 upvotes)

Tips from the Community

Start with the discovery set: It’s the most mentioned entry point “I bought the discovery set. I kind of like Dark is Night.” (15 upvotes)
Layering can enhance performance: “Delizia layers really well with Kayali Yum Boujee Marshmallow”
A good option for sensitive users: Often recommended for people with skin sensitivities or fragrance-triggered headaches

Final verdict

Scents like Sheep’s Clothing, Flora Carnivora, and Queens & Monsters definitely have fans, but frequent complaints about longevity, underwhelming packaging, and overhyped clean beauty messaging keep some people from buying full bottles.

If you’re someone with fragrance sensitivities, ingredient allergies, or just want to smell like Michelle Pfeiffer, Henry Rose might be worth sampling. People recommend you to start with a the henry rose discovery set.