Stay updated on new reviews

Uninfluenced Review

Is By Rosie Jane Fragrance Worth It?

Written by

Eva Chartwell

We collected Reddit discussions about By Rosie Jane fragrances to see what people are saying about the brand and what’s worth buying.


The Good

  • Dulce (Fan Favorite): “I love Dulce by Rosie Jane, don’t listen to them saying it smells like a bootleg Bianco Latte.” (29 upvotes) “It’s an airy caramel, chocolatey vanilla… one of my favorite autumn/winter fragrances.” (22 upvotes) “I like it, it’s like a coffee vibe.” (9 upvotes)
  • Leila Lou (Fresh & Floral): “Leila Lou smells really nice to me! Like jasmine and fresh cut grass and sweetness.” (18 upvotes)
  • Dylan (Highly Recommended): “I got ahold of Dylan and it’s amazing.” (15 upvotes)
  • Rosie (Complex but Wearable): “I prefer Rosie as it has a bit more warmth… still easy to wear.” (12 upvotes)


The Not So Good

  • Artificial Quality: “I found it too artificial… smelled like a Yankee candle to me.” (12 upvotes) “Dulce might not be for you, it kinda smells like Ikea candle, melted ice cream with a hint of chocolate.” (29 upvotes)
  • Weak Performance: “I think the smell is very faint and doesn’t last long.” (12 upvotes)
  • Packaging Issues: Some users reported faulty sprayers, forcing them to decant into atomizers.


Tips & Tricks

  • Layering: Popular method for boosting performance. “Mix it with the vanilla fragrance and you have vanilla latte.” (9 upvotes)
  • Atomizers: Workaround for faulty sprayers. “Buy a pack of atomizers on Amazon for under $10 and transfer Rosie Jane into one.” (12 upvotes)
  • Oil vs. EDP: Some prefer oils for longevity and intensity. “I have the fragrance and the oil and prefer the oil.” (22 upvotes)


Verdict?

Reddit community see  By Rosie Jane as a niche between mass-market body sprays and high-end perfume. Dulce stands out as the star fragrance, but across the line, longevity and projection are recurring concerns. Many buyers still find the scents worth it because they’re approachable, subtle, and easy to wear daily. The consensus: great everyday fragrances if you don’t mind reapplying, but not for those seeking bold, long-lasting performance

Leave a comment