The Good

• Softness & Feel – Many buyers praise the comfort and touch.
  • “The Clara cashmere cardigan is super soft, nice structure, hasn’t pilled at all after quite a few wears. I reach for it often and I’m super picky about sweaters / fabric.” (13 upvotes)
  • “I have it in red and I love it 🥰… Super soft and nice colour.” (10 upvotes)
• Worth the Price for Some “I found Ref’s cashmere is generally worth the money. If you find a style that you like, do it!” (9 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Itchiness & Heat Sensitivity – Some experience irritation, especially when warm. “It’s very soft and buttery, but if I get hot/start to sweat in it then it’s very itchy.” (9 upvotes)
• Quality Disappointments – Not all purchases met expectations. “I dropped a shit ton on Reformation this year and that cashmere sweater is the only thing I returned.” (33 upvotes)
• Thickness Variations – “The Jadey is a lot thicker while the  Boyfriend cashmere is a thin style cashmere.” (11 upvotes)

Comparison to Alternatives

• J.Crew – Mentioned frequently for comparison, with mixed conclusions on value.
• Everlane – Used as a cautionary example for poor durability. “Looking at you Everlane cashmere that pilled after less than one season.” (13 upvotes)
• Banana Republic – Highlighted for quality at a lower price. “Very similar sweater… super high quality and it was only $100 (now 40% off).” (9 upvotes)

Tips and Tricks

• Care Instructions – Dry Clean or Hand wash in wool-specific detergent for less itch; dry clean to avoid shrinkage.
  • “Lanolin… coats the fibres and makes it less itchy.” (19 upvotes)
  • “I have to brush all of them from time to time.” (24 upvotes)
  • “I only dry clean the cashmere jumpers… too much money at stake 😅” (10 upvotes)
• Watch for sales and consignment influxes after bi-annual events. “Slight uptick in TRR listings after Reformation’s bi-annual sales.” (8 upvotes)
• Style & Color Selection – Softness can vary by color. “I found the black to be softer than blue.” (7 upvotes)

The Verdict

Reformation cashmere gets praise for softness, color, and style – but not every piece lives up to the $200+ price tag. Quality varies by style and color, with some items running thin, scratchy, or prone to pilling. Buyers who wait for sales or shop secondhand report far better value. The Jadey cashmerer sweater and Clara Cashmere Cardigan receives repeated positive mentions, while thinner options warrant extra caution. Proper care—via dry cleaning or gentle hand washing—helps maintain softness and longevity.

---