Praised for its slouchy-chic design and criticized for some quality concerns, the Rodeo has sparked lively debate among fashion enthusiasts on Reddit

The Good

Versatile and functional

• “Best bag I’ve ever owned—prefer it to my Hermes, Chanel, YSL, and Gucci bags.” (12 upvotes)
• “Love the mini. Holds everything I need. It’s held up well, and it’s such a great bag to carry. I’d definitely recommend it.” (7 upvotes)
• “For travel, it’s perfect. Docs in the front pouch, and you just lift your arm and your passport is out—so convenient.” (5 upvotes)

Design Devotion

• “I love, love, love the Rodeo!! I have two sizes in black and I definitely want another color.” (25 upvotes)
• “The hype over the Rodeo is WELL deserved. I have a medium from Kata and it’s my everyday bag.” (12 upvotes)
• “I ended up with two extra Rodeos after my first one. I’m a sucker for bigger, structured bags.” (5 upvotes)

The Not So Food

Strap Flaws

• “My coworker said she was walking with her Rodeo when the strap just fell off out of nowhere.” (25 upvotes)
• “The attachable strap is super thin and uncomfortable. Makes the bag feel heavy and it swings a lot when worn.” (5 upvotes)

Hardware Issues & Durability concerns

• “If the bag is full, the hardware sometimes opens up and things fall out—it just gives away.” (5 upvotes)
• “The hardware feels low quality to me, and I’m a bit worried about it.” (5 upvotes)
• “The leather scratches easily, and the thin strap doesn’t feel made for a heavy load.” (5 upvotes)

How It Compares

To Other Designer Bags

• “Feels like a mix of the Hermes Kelly and the Peekaboo Soft.” (5 upvotes)
• “It does look like a Peekaboo—which makes sense because I love my Peekaboo too.” (7 upvotes)

Alternative Brands

• “Bottega Veneta’s new Andiamo has a similar aesthetic if you want something comparable.” (6 upvotes)
• “Furla Sfera Soft is another great alternative.” (6 upvotes)

Tips from Redditors

Adjusting the Strap

“Tying a knot looks dumb, but this YouTuber threaded the strap through the top handle and clipped both ends to one side. Helped shorten it a lot.” (5 upvotes)

Getting That Slouch

• “Use Saphir leather conditioner, attach charms, and let it hang out. Got a great slouch after.” (11 upvotes)
• “I don’t want to baby this bag. I want it slouchy and chic—think Mary-Kate and Ashley with their Birkins.” (12 upvotes)

Laptop Compatibility

• “If you unsnap the sides, it fits a 13” MacBook. The medium is perfect for everyday use.” (6 upvotes)
• “Even with a laptop inside, there’s still room for your other stuff.” (6 upvotes)

Final Verdict

The Balenciaga Rodeo bag gets serious love on Reddit for its effortless style, travel-friendliness, and spacious design- especially in the medium size. But it’s not without flaws: users consistently call out the thin strap and questionable hardware. If you’re into a slouchy, structured everyday bag with that high-fashion look, the Rodeo might just be worth it!!

---