If you’ve been eyeing those beautiful leather journals from Paper Republic that’s viral on TikTok and wondering if they’re worth the splurge, you’re not alone. Hope these reddit community reviews can help you.

---

The Good

• People love the modular, customizable system: “I liked the modularity of it. Previously I had issues with the bullet journaling system because while, in theory, it’s modular, I prefer to keep similar topics together which is hard to do with the bujo system. With TN though, I can have a notebook for each topic” (30 upvotes)
• The leather quality adds character over time: “It’s leather; it’s never going to be perfect. This is probably a particularly porous spot on the leather that absorbed a bit more dye. It just gives it character and personality.” (29 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Most acknowledge these are luxury items: “I think you hit the nail on the head. Luxury goods are luxury goods for a reason – they’re nonessential but bring happiness to those with the means or disposition to appreciate them. If Louise Carmen notebooks are what you want then no one else’s opinion matters.” (36 upvotes)
• Some find the system can become overly complex: Several users mentioned moving away from complicated systems to simpler solutions
• The price point is difficult to justify for many casual journal users

Common Considerations

• The leather naturally has imperfections: Most users see variations in dye absorption as part of the charm rather than defects
• Some find themselves simplifying over time: “This was my fourth year with Hobonichi and I’m considering leaving behind my Weeks next year! My life has gotten far more routine, so I may just go back to a monthly calendar for appointment tracking” (20 upvotes)
• Many experiment with different insert options: “I am still going to get a new cover, but im going to just use a blank midori grid notebook and draw out the layouts from the pages I actually use from the original hobo myself” (54 upvotes)

Alternatives Worth Considering

• The Midori Traveler’s Notebook is frequently mentioned: Many users discuss switching between Midori and Paper Republic systems
• Some prefer ring-bound systems for flexibility: “I’m officially moving onto a rings system next year! It’s been so hit and miss in my weeks and cousin this year (I think me and the new paper aren’t getting along) and even though I never thought I’d be a rings person it’s working SO well for me since June!” (27 upvotes)
• Budget alternatives like Daiso notebooks work in similar covers: “Same size as what fits the [Endless Explorer] covers, then. I just use cheap [B6 notebooks sold by Daiso] in my Endless Explorer.” (25 upvotes)

Worth it?

• These are recognized as luxury items: “Luxury goods are luxury goods for a reason – they’re nonessential but bring happiness to those with the means or disposition to appreciate them.” (36 upvotes)
• The value comes from personalization: Many users appreciate the ability to tailor their journal system exactly to their needs
• Creating DIY inserts can reduce ongoing costs: “Invest in a cutting mat, rotary blade (like for quilting), a metal ruler, and a long arm stapler (for booklet making). These tools are some of the best/most used items I’ve ever owned since using travelers notebooks for a decade.” (18 upvotes)

Pro Tips

• Invest in tools for making custom inserts: “Invest in a cutting mat, rotary blade (like for quilting), a metal ruler, and a long arm stapler (for booklet making). These tools are some of the best/most used items I’ve ever owned since using travelers notebooks for a decade. The options are unlimited with them.” (18 upvotes)
• Consider simplifying your system: “I may just go back to a monthly calendar for appointment tracking with random scrap paper to-do lists.” (20 upvotes)
• Try alternative, less expensive inserts: “I just use cheap [B6 notebooks sold by Daiso] in my Endless Explorer.” (25 upvotes)

Final Verdict

Paper Republic journals represent a niche but passionate corner of the stationery world:

• The modular, customizable system is the primary appeal for most users
• The leather covers develop character over time and are seen as an investment
• Most recognize these as luxury items that provide joy beyond mere functionality
• Many users enjoy the journey of personalizing their system through DIY inserts or compatible alternatives
• For those who value flexibility and aesthetics in their journal system, the consensus is that the investment is worthwhile

The Reddit consensus suggests Paper Republic journals are best suited for those who appreciate luxury stationery, enjoy personalizing their planning system, and value the distinctive aesthetic of leather journal covers that evolve with use.

---