Stay updated on new reviews

Uninfluenced Review

Is Hatch Maternity Clothing Worth It?

Written by

Eva Chartwell

We combed through reddit discussions about Hatch Maternity Clothing span multiple threads and product categories — from leggings and joggers to jeans, bras, sweaters, and special-occasion dresses.

The overall tone is nuanced: users genuinely love a few standout pieces, particularly soft, stretchy staples and event dresses, but many question whether the brand consistently delivers on its premium price point. Satisfaction often depends on the specific item purchased, and more importantly, how much was paid for it.

The Good

  • Before/During/After Leggings
    • “The ultra soft before, during, and after leggings are expensive, but the cost per use is probably the lowest of my leggings because I liked them best and wore them through 2 pregnancies.” (3 upvotes)
    • “The before/during/after leggings have fit me from 19 weeks – 38 weeks with no problems so far… They are super comfortable and shrink to their initial size when you wash them instead of becoming floppy and worn out.” (2 upvotes)
  • Joggers
    • “I have a pair of Hatch joggers and they are soooo comfy. I still wear them PP too.” (2 upvotes)
  • Rompers & Loungewear
    • “I got one of their one piece romper type things and it is such amazing quality and so comfy! Highly recommend.” (1 upvote)
  • Occasion Dresses
    • “The Hatch visitor dress is awesome. So comfy.” (3 upvotes)
    • “My baby shower dress was from Hatch and it happened to work great for me and I got tons of compliments on it, even from people who just saw me in photos.” (2 upvotes)
  • Postpartum Wearability
    • “Most of them look like you could also wear them post-partum/non-pregnant… That makes it somewhat more worth the price, but only somewhat.” (2 upvotes)


The Not So Good

  • Quality Concerns
    • “I have a few pieces I bought second hand. Honestly, they’re SO not worth the cost. The jeans are all weirdly cropped, and I’m only 5’8″. The merino sweaters I have are insanely itchy… The cashmere blend sweater I have is itchy and pills like crazy.” (10 upvotes)
    • “After TWO WEARS the leggings came unsewn in like 7 different places. They were the most useful piece of the whole kit, too!” (4 upvotes)
    • “I hate all of the clothes that were sent to me… The nursing dress X2 in black and sage [is] same quality as Forever 21, not exaggerating.” (2 upvotes)
    • “I splurged on the cashmere robe there and it didn’t even feel like cashmere… all the buttons were impossible to open because of a terrible threading job on the buttonholes.” (2 upvotes)
  • Sizing Inconsistency (0/1/2/3 System)
    • “I needed a different size in each style of jeans, dresses, etc.”
    • “Third trimester there’s so much I got that’s not fitting over the bump, which isn’t a problem I’ve had with any other brand.”
  • See-Through Fabric
    • Multiple users reported that the “ultra soft” leggings can be see-through, especially when bending.
  • Itchy Materials
    • Merino and cashmere blends repeatedly described as uncomfortable without layering.
  • Return Shipping Fees
    • “I ordered a ton of stuff from them and returned 75%… I was horrified they charged me for return shipping. It’s not like they have a store I could have gone to. It felt super icky.” (4 upvotes)
  • Inventory Issues
    • At least one user reported being notified after purchase that an item was oversold, with shipping already deducted from a gift card.


Comparison to Alternatives

  • Quince
    • “Quince bamboo maternity leggings are way cheaper, and I found they were more comfortable too.”
    • Frequently praised for third-trimester comfort.
  • Lululemon (Align leggings)
    • “Absolutely worth every penny… supportive without being constricting, they grow with you.” (3 upvotes)
  • Kindred Bravely
    • “Super comfortable and cute. And they frequently have sales/bundles too.” (4 upvotes)
  • Seraphine
    • “I loved loved loved [Seraphine] during my pregnancy 7 years ago!”
  • Target (Isabel Maternity)
    • Affordable, stretchy basics that hold up through third trimester.
  • Amazon / Shein
    • Budget-friendly options that surprised users with decent quality.
  • Nothing Fits But
    • “I got a dupe of the visitor dress from Nothing Fits But at a drastically lower price point and I think it’s adorable! This review makes me glad I didn’t go for Hatch.” (11 upvotes)
  • Secondhand Platforms
    • The RealReal
    • Poshmark
    • “I have the James dress from TRR… for the $65 I paid, 100% worth it.” (2 upvotes)
  • Retail Alternative
    • Shopbop recommended for easier returns and occasional markdowns.


Tips & Tricks

  • Shop secondhand first (The RealReal, Poshmark) for 50–75% off retail.
  • Buy through Shopbop for faster shipping and easier returns.
  • Stick to “hero” pieces: before/during/after leggings, joggers, select dresses.
  • Avoid structured items like button-downs and bras.
  • Prioritize full-panel bottoms over side-panel styles for third-trimester support.
  • Order carefully due to paid return shipping.
  • Wait for major sales (Black Friday and periodic 25%+ discounts).
  • Verify fabric composition when buying resale.


The Verdict


Across Reddit, Hatch is viewed as a stylish but inconsistent premium maternity brand.

The before/during/after leggings, joggers, and certain dresses earn repeated praise for comfort and versatility, especially when worn beyond pregnancy.

However, complaints about itchy fabrics, quality inconsistencies, confusing sizing, and paid return shipping make many users hesitant to recommend buying at full retail.

Most positive experiences are tied to gift cards, major discounts, or secondhand purchases — suggesting that Hatch’s perceived value improves significantly when the price drops.

Leave a comment