Moccamaster, has developed a cult following among coffee enthusiasts, with recurring themes of longevity, consistency, and quality, alongside critiques of price, build materials, and uneven brewing performance in reddit discussions..

---

The Good

• Longevity and Reliability 
  • “The Moccamaster is the best coffee maker ever. Mine is 11 years old and no problems.” (64 upvotes)
  •  “My Moccamaster is 23 years old daily use. Just cleaned it up last week.” (30 upvotes) 
  • “It’s honestly one of the best things I have purchased. Would have loved a 50% off but 0 regrets after using it almost every day for the last 4 years.” (7 upvotes)

• Coffee Quality is Top Notch
  •  “One cup and I was hooked. I immediately placed an order online at $349 and don’t regret it one bit… It makes a far superior cup than anywhere else.” (45 upvotes)
  •  “I was genuinely pissed off that I waited as long as I did to have a really good cup of coffee. Still to this day, the only thing that I regret is not buying the Moccamaster sooner.” (8 upvotes)

• Proper Brewing Temperature is Key 
  • “The Moccamasters brew at the correct temperature… There’s a big difference in coffee taste brewed at different temps.” (30 upvotes)
  •  “The Moccamaster is extremely consistent. 197° 100% of the time and that makes the difference.” (8 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Build Quality Concerns “I’m disappointed with the build quality. For €250 I expected more than cheap plastic.”

• Uneven Brewing “Had exactly the same experience with the MM, extremely uneven saturation with multiple dry spots, even after tweaking grind and spout location.” (7 upvotes)

• Amazon Quality Issues “Check out posts on r/moccamaster from about this time last year. Dozens if not hundreds of posts of people complaining about getting broken/used Moccamaster from Amazon on Prime Day.” (59 upvotes)

• Plastic Components Some buyers dislike the plastic look, though defenders point out: “Moccamaster plastics do not contain bisphenols (BPA, BPF, BPS) or phthalates… they’re actually high-level food- and beverage-safe plastics.” (200 upvotes)

Comparison to Alternatives

• Bonavita “The Bonavita is at our farmhouse which we visit a couple of weekends out of the month. Agreed the Technivorm is the best but the Bonavita is a close second.” (8 upvotes) “Our Bonavita crapped out after 2 years, replaced with a Moccamaster and it’s still going years later.” (7 upvotes)
• Breville Precision Brewer “I believe the Breville can probably make a better cup of coffee without any fiddling, but I also believe that a Moccamaster will probably still be brewing coffee after you’ve gone through 2–3 Brevilles.” (10 upvotes)
• Fellow Aiden “Moccamaster’s the reliable workhorse, brews great every time and lasts forever. Fellow Aiden’s more modern, better if your dad’s into the craft and precision side of coffee.” (10 upvotes)

The Verdict

The Reddit consensus on the Moccamaster is broadly positive: it delivers excellent coffee at the proper brewing temperature and is built to last decades with minimal maintenance. Owners frequently highlight 10–20+ years of use, calling it a “buy once” investment.

Criticism typically revolves around the plastic parts, design quirks, uneven brewing with half-pots, and quality control when buying via Amazon. The premium price is a hurdle, but many justify it as a long-term investment, especially when paired with a quality burr grinder.