The Good

• Softness and comfort“It’s very soft!!” (6 upvotes)
• Easy-to-style basics“I love the t-shirt style cashmere sweater. It is cute, easy to style and I can throw it on with a pair of slacks for work.” (8 upvotes)
• Standout styles“I have several cashmere sweaters from Quince—happy with all of them. If I had to pick a favorite, fisherman crewneck.” (7 upvotes)
• Durability with careful care“The cashmere is thick and soft… washed cold on delicate and hang dry. No shrinkage.” (1 upvote)
• Machine washing (with precautions)“Machine washed in cold/delicate with laundry bag and dried flat.” (4 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Hit-or-miss quality“Quince can be very hit or miss… they do an especially poor job with luxury knits like cashmere.” (57 upvotes)
• Heavy pilling“It’s nice but pills A LOT. Needs to be brushed all the time to look nice.” (2 upvotes)
• Short lifespan“It fit well, but it wore out SO quickly.” (1 upvote)
• Shrinkage complaints“They all shrank after washing in cold water with wool-safe detergent.” (5 upvotes)
• Side Effects & Common Concerns

Comparison to Alternatives

Higher-End Cashmere Brands

• Clear quality difference“I also have a Missoni cashmere sweater and I can really tell the difference.” (75 upvotes)
• Secondhand luxury recommended“Secondhand cashmere from a real cashmere house is miles better.” (18 upvotes)
• Cost breakdown reality check“The yarn alone for quality cashmere can cost more than many ‘cheap cashmere’ sweaters retail for.” (144 upvotes)

Similar Price-Tier Brands

• Comparable to other mid-tier brands“On par with Naadam and J.Crew—and that’s not a compliment.” (57 upvotes)
• Better than some department store options“Quince is thicker and softer than Macy’s or Bloomingdale’s at the same price.” (1 upvote)
• Uniqlo & Everlane comparisons“The Uniqlo one was much more poorly made.” (9 upvotes)

The Verdict

Reddit sentiment toward Quince cashmere is mixed but informed. Many users enjoy the initial softness and affordability, especially as an entry point into cashmere. However, experienced shoppers consistently flag issues with pilling, shrinkage, inconsistent sizing, and short lifespan, often attributing these problems to short-staple fibers and cost-cutting construction.

The dominant consensus is that Quince cashmere can be acceptable for the price, but it is not true quality cashmere. People who prioritize longevity, structure, and sustainability are frequently advised to either buy secondhand from established cashmere houses or explore alternative fibers like alpaca or yak.

---