The Good

• Good for the price: “Perfectly serviceable, but not buy-it-for-life quality.” (44 upvotes)
• Strong customer service: “They’re sending me a replacement. Customer service is 10/10.” (36 upvotes)
• Affordable luxury lookalike: “I love the Puzzle but can’t afford it right now. I’ll definitely be picking this up!!” (266 upvotes)
• Solid individual experiences: “I have two bags from them that I’m obsessed with and have really great quality.” (36 upvotes)
• Cute, no glaring issues: “It arrived yesterday. I’m happy with the purchase—it’s cute and no quality issues.” (20 upvotes)

The Not So Good

• Poor leather feel: “Bought a knockoff Clare V Fanny from Quince and the leather was horrible. Returned immediately.” (19 upvotes)
• Questionable sourcing: “Wouldn’t be surprised if it’s recycled scrap of unknown origin. That’s why reviews are so inconsistent.” (313 upvotes)
• Durability issues: “The one bag I got from them I returned.” (89 upvotes)
• Underwhelming in person: “I have the brown one. It feels very underwhelming IRL.” (41 upvotes)
• Questionable accuracy: “They said top grain from Italy but it was actually split leather.” (18 upvotes)
• Compare vs. Coach: “Quince has audacity to come at Coach—Coach quality is consistently very good, sometimes better than pricier brands.” (90 upvotes) “Blatant lie comparing to Coach handbags.” (39 upvotes)

Comparison to Alternatives

• Luxury bags: Users note clear quality differences. “Leather quality on my secondhand Flamenco is way better, but it’s not $3,000 better.” (17 upvotes)
• Coach: Often cited as superior and more reliable at a comparable or slightly higher price point.
• Reformation: “Just looking at the photos, the Reformation one looks a lot nicer.” (43 upvotes)
• Secondhand & vintage: Many suggest going secondhand for real quality at similar prices.

Worth It because:

• Dupes and affordability: “This bag is great for a $120 version of the bag!!” (17 upvotes)
• Reasonable expectations: “Not sure why anyone expects a $100 bag to be heirloom quality.” (21 upvotes)
• Budget tradeoff: “I’d rather put $4k in my 401k than buy the original.” (170 upvotes)

Not Worth It because:

• Disappointing leather: “Returned immediately—felt cheap.” (19 upvotes)
• Better alternatives exist: Secondhand and vintage are repeatedly recommended as higher-value choices.
• Inconsistent experiences: Too much variation in quality across items.

The Verdict

Reddit consensus frames Quince leather bags as “good for the price but not luxury quality.” While some buyers are satisfied with the aesthetics and customer service, others are disappointed by plasticky leather, inconsistent craftsmanship, and misleading marketing.

---