Is Hims& Hers Hair Loss Treatment Worth it According to Reddit? What are the Pros and Cons?

The Good

Give it a few months — some users report noticeable regrowth

Some users shared dramatic before-and-after improvements in density and overall appearance. “goddamn! my man came back from the dead 💯 great result” (3 upvotes)
Other commenters noticed improvement even when the original poster was still relatively early in treatment. “hair def looks better so just keep it up and stay consistent” (5 upvotes)

The pill is much easier to stick with than topical minoxidil

Convenience is one of the clearest advantages users mention. One person switched after struggling to consistently use topical minoxidil. “I was using Costco minoxidil foam. Some biotin shampoo. And it was just a pain. I’d take big breaks. The pills are just easier to do. I just take it with breakfast and daily multi vitamin.” (1 upvote)
For people who dislike applying foam or spray every day, the oral format may make consistency easier — which matters with treatments that need to be taken continuously.

The chewable version is easy to take

One user described the Hims chewable simply as “Like candy.” (1 upvote)

The Not So Good

Results are definitely not guaranteed

Some users reported continuing to lose hair despite taking the same treatment for several months. “Literally using the same thing since I think march and it has only gotten worse. Hate you :’)” (1 upvote)
The wide variation in Reddit before-and-after posts is a good reminder that response differs significantly from person to person.

Don’t expect your original hairline to necessarily come back

One user saw no meaningful change to a longstanding widow’s peak. “I haven’t noticed that at all. I’ve had a widows peak since Highschool. Still there.” (1 upvote)
In general, Reddit discussions tend to show stronger results around increased density and slowing further loss than completely rebuilding a long-receded hairline.

Dramatic before-and-afters sometimes draw skepticism

Particularly impressive transformation posts occasionally get challenged by other users, including blunt responses like “Fake!” (1 upvote)
Lighting, hair length, styling, wet vs. dry hair, and camera angle can all make Reddit progress photos difficult to compare objectively.

Sexual side effects are one of the biggest concerns around finasteride

One user reported no change in sex drive or erectile function but did notice reduced ejaculatory volume. “my sex drive hasn’t lowered, I haven’t experienced ED, but when finishing, it isn’t quite a release anymore, more of a trickle.” (1 upvote)
Another user described a similar change and wondered whether it could affect fertility. “Probably harder to have kids right now. Production is not the same. Not ED. That’s all good.” (1 upvote)
These are individual Reddit experiences rather than evidence that the medication will affect everyone this way. Anyone concerned about sexual or reproductive side effects should discuss them with their prescriber.

Comparison to Alternatives

Oral treatment is easier than Costco minoxidil foam for some users

The biggest advantage over topical minoxidil isn’t necessarily better results — it’s convenience. One user explained that foam became difficult to maintain consistently, while taking a pill with breakfast was easy to turn into a habit.
This can matter because both minoxidil and finasteride generally require ongoing use to maintain their benefits.

The Hims spray gets more mixed feedback

Some users who discussed both formats reported seeing little noticeable growth with the Hims spray before switching to an oral finasteride/minoxidil combination.
That doesn’t establish that the oral treatment works better overall, but convenience and adherence appear to be major reasons Reddit users prefer it.

Hims is mostly a convenient way to access established hair-loss medications

One commenter described Hims simply as a “brand that sells fin/min and other products.” (4 upvotes)
That captures an important distinction: Reddit users generally aren’t treating Hims itself as the breakthrough. The appeal is convenient access, packaging, and delivery of medications such as finasteride and minoxidil.

The Value of Hims & Hers

You’re partly paying for convenience

Prices mentioned in the Reddit discussions included around $178 for a 90-day supply and roughly $170 for a 180-count supply, although pricing can vary by treatment and subscription.
Users didn’t complain heavily about the price, but several asked how much the treatment cost — suggesting affordability is still an important consideration.
The strongest value proposition appears to be convenience: prescription access, combination formulations, automatic delivery, and avoiding the daily hassle of topical treatment.

Tips & Tricks

Don’t judge the treatment after only a month or two

Reddit users frequently remind people that hair-loss treatment is a long game. “That’s only 2 months dude, don’t people shed for that long or more?” (2 upvotes)
Early progress photos can therefore be misleading in either direction.

Expect periods where shedding makes you question whether it’s working

Users warn that shedding can happen even after initially encouraging results. “Wait for a year from now and then it starts to all fall out and you freak out. It comes back though.” (1 upvote)
A Reddit anecdote can’t tell you whether any individual shedding episode is normal, so significant or concerning changes are worth discussing with the prescribing clinician rather than simply assuming they’re part of the process.

Give it around six months before making conclusions

Patience is one of the most common pieces of advice in the threads. “just hang in there another 3 months and you’ll look even better.” (1 upvote)
Many users evaluate their progress over months rather than weeks.

Don’t rely on biotin as your main hair-regrowth treatment

One Reddit commenter claimed “The biotin stops or reduces the shed that’s it’s only purpose.” (1 upvote)
That’s a user opinion rather than established evidence. Biotin supplements aren’t generally considered a proven hair-loss treatment unless someone has an underlying deficiency.

Bottom Line

Reddit experiences with Hims oral finasteride/minoxidil treatment are encouraging but far from universal. Some users report substantial improvements in density after several months, while others see little progress or even continued thinning.

The clearest advantage of Hims may actually be convenience. Users who struggled with the daily routine of minoxidil foam or spray find taking a pill much easier to maintain.

The tradeoff is that these are real prescription medications, not simply hair supplements. Finasteride-related sexual side effects and oral minoxidil’s cardiovascular risks are recurring concerns worth understanding before starting.

If you’re considering it, the Reddit playbook is essentially: stay consistent, give it months rather than weeks, track your progress with comparable photos, and talk with your prescriber if side effects show up.